My tensioner pulley (drive idler) died, so I got a used one. This new one seems to spin just fine and if I grab the pulley and the arrow indicator plate I can rotate it by hand and the spring will rotate it back when I let go. Though when I install it and try pushing it down with a crowbar the pointer doesn’t rotate. Even if I try to help it get started and rotate it some by hand it still won’t move any further with the crowbar. I tried spraying the backside with WD40 to help it not stick, but it’s still not rotating. Not sure if this means it’s defective or what.