Harbor Freight Wire-Feed Welders

Help Support SkidSteer Forum:

SkidRoe

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 10, 2009
Messages
1,885
I just bought one of their 170 Amp 240 volt welders to replace my old 110 volt MIG. The price was what sold me. I figured for $170, it was worth a try. For my usage, I really can't justify spending big bucks on a name brand, and I have a Lincoln 225 AC/DC stick welder as well. Anybody else using one of these? Good/bad experiences?
 

Tazza

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Dec 7, 2004
Messages
16,839
It all depends on what size material you want to weld. I had a 190 amp MIG for quite a few years, it worked great. I then got the option to buy a 250 amp machine for $900. I took the larger machine and sold my 190A machine, i can't remember what the change over value was but it was worth it. 170A is heaps for lighter gauge material, just don't expect it to do deep welds in 1/2" plate.
As you already have the heavy duty stick, i can't see there will be anything you won't still be able to tackle.
What wire are you using? flux cored or are you using shielding gas? i run solid wire, but currently out of shielding gas...... Isn't that always the way?
 
OP
OP
SkidRoe

SkidRoe

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 10, 2009
Messages
1,885
It all depends on what size material you want to weld. I had a 190 amp MIG for quite a few years, it worked great. I then got the option to buy a 250 amp machine for $900. I took the larger machine and sold my 190A machine, i can't remember what the change over value was but it was worth it. 170A is heaps for lighter gauge material, just don't expect it to do deep welds in 1/2" plate.
As you already have the heavy duty stick, i can't see there will be anything you won't still be able to tackle.
What wire are you using? flux cored or are you using shielding gas? i run solid wire, but currently out of shielding gas...... Isn't that always the way?
No worries, I have no delusions of setting the world on fire with this welder. Most of the materials that I weld are 1/4" or less, which this welder is capable of. On the odd occasion that I do weld thicker materials, I typically run multi-pass welds. If I really need to get serious, Pops has a 250 amp 100% duty cycle machine at his place, about half an hour away. I run ER70S solid wire. Running out of gas is never an issue for me. The shop across the street is a depot for the local weld gas supplier. My concern is more about the longevity of these machines. As indicated by the price, these machines are obviously of off-shore origin, likely made by the C.H. Ina Company. I have never bought anything of the magnitude from HF and want to temper my expectations accordingly. Cheers!
 

Tazza

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Dec 7, 2004
Messages
16,839
No worries, I have no delusions of setting the world on fire with this welder. Most of the materials that I weld are 1/4" or less, which this welder is capable of. On the odd occasion that I do weld thicker materials, I typically run multi-pass welds. If I really need to get serious, Pops has a 250 amp 100% duty cycle machine at his place, about half an hour away. I run ER70S solid wire. Running out of gas is never an issue for me. The shop across the street is a depot for the local weld gas supplier. My concern is more about the longevity of these machines. As indicated by the price, these machines are obviously of off-shore origin, likely made by the C.H. Ina Company. I have never bought anything of the magnitude from HF and want to temper my expectations accordingly. Cheers!
Hopefully it will still do all you need and give good service, but you already know it won't be as good as a more expensive unit. I assume it would have a 1 year warranty, i'm sure they wouldn't being them in if they were absolute rubbish.
I had a giggle about the not setting the world on fire, i know i have tried to set my shop on fire multiple times with my welder, never on purpose though :)
 
OP
OP
SkidRoe

SkidRoe

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 10, 2009
Messages
1,885
Hopefully it will still do all you need and give good service, but you already know it won't be as good as a more expensive unit. I assume it would have a 1 year warranty, i'm sure they wouldn't being them in if they were absolute rubbish.
I had a giggle about the not setting the world on fire, i know i have tried to set my shop on fire multiple times with my welder, never on purpose though :)
It actually has 27 months of warranty. I bought the additional 2 years for $30. Seemed like cheap insurance.
 

1ofU

Well-known member
Joined
May 19, 2012
Messages
180
It actually has 27 months of warranty. I bought the additional 2 years for $30. Seemed like cheap insurance.
if the welder has a 60% duty cycle is should be ok ,, i havent seen or used one of those welders so you need to post back after some burn time so other may know to purchase or stay away from . i run Hobart/Lincoln migs & Monky wards and Lincoln sticks at home at work i use a commander 300 as well as SA200 out in the yard and Miller 452/652 in the steel shop .
 
OP
OP
SkidRoe

SkidRoe

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 10, 2009
Messages
1,885
if the welder has a 60% duty cycle is should be ok ,, i havent seen or used one of those welders so you need to post back after some burn time so other may know to purchase or stay away from . i run Hobart/Lincoln migs & Monky wards and Lincoln sticks at home at work i use a commander 300 as well as SA200 out in the yard and Miller 452/652 in the steel shop .
It supposedly has a 20% duty cycle, running a 110A. I am not planning on going into the bucket fabrication business (loooooong weld seams), so it should be fine for me. I have a Lincoln 225 AC/DC stick machine as well, and I don't mind using stick. MIG is just so much nicer for tacking.
I welded up a clamp-on bucket hitch the other day with it and, so far, I am pretty impressed with it. For $200 (including the extend warranty), what the hey??
 

1816case

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 13, 2015
Messages
138
It supposedly has a 20% duty cycle, running a 110A. I am not planning on going into the bucket fabrication business (loooooong weld seams), so it should be fine for me. I have a Lincoln 225 AC/DC stick machine as well, and I don't mind using stick. MIG is just so much nicer for tacking.
I welded up a clamp-on bucket hitch the other day with it and, so far, I am pretty impressed with it. For $200 (including the extend warranty), what the hey??
Just wondering.. How the Chicago Electric welder is holding up? I got to be honest and say I heard to stay away from them.. cheap circuit boards (built cheap- not cheap to buy) and heard lots of plastic in wire feed areas? I never owned one ( got my Dad's old Linde) so just wondering if true or not. You use your warranty on it? Hope it is holding up well.
 
Top